{"id":"clean-cooking","title":"Clean-fuel stoves (the largest trial found no clear pneumonia benefit)","claim":"A large multi-country trial that gave households LPG stoves and fuel did not find a significant reduction in severe infant pneumonia, so health benefits are less certain than often assumed.","label":"mixed evidence","implementability":{"cost":"high","cost_note":"Stove plus continuing fuel supply","adoption":"piloted","channel":"clean-cooking programmes","actors":"energy ministries","score":5,"practical":true,"band":"implementable with effort"},"design":"trial","verdict":"mixed","problems":["cooking","air"],"domains":["Energy and air"],"verified":"not yet checked against the source","works_where":"Guatemala, India, Peru and Rwanda, 2018-2021.","takes":"Stoves, a reliable fuel supply, and support for exclusive use of the clean stove.","who":"Energy and health ministries, clean-cooking programmes.","first_test":"Measure household exposure (PM2.5) before and after in 100 homes to check the stove is actually used exclusively before claiming health gains.","limits":"Mixed result: mixed fuel use can leave exposure high; exposure and other outcomes (blood pressure, birth weight) have separate reports.","sources":[{"cite":"Clasen and the HAPIN investigators, New England Journal of Medicine, 2022","finding":"Randomised trial of a liquefied petroleum gas stove intervention in Guatemala, India, Peru and Rwanda: no significant reduction in severe pneumonia in infants.","links":["https://europepmc.org/search?query=Clasen%20and%20the%20HAPIN%20investigators%2C%20New%20England%20Journal%20of%20Medicine%2C%202022"]}],"url":"https://tenant-ps-web.ultrastable.workers.dev/solutions/clean-cooking","cite":"Practical Solutions. \"Clean-fuel stoves (the largest trial found no clear pneumonia benefit)\". https://tenant-ps-web.ultrastable.workers.dev/solutions/clean-cooking. Accessed 2026-11-17."}