{"id":"elder-teaching-at-the-right-level","title":"Teach children at the right level using older adults as the teachers","status":"proposed combination, not yet tested as a combination","headline":"Retired people deliver the proven daily skill-grouping lessons for children who cannot yet read, and the programme is also measured as a loneliness intervention for the older adults.","domain":"Education and Health","problem":"Children not learning to read, and older adults who are isolated","transfer":{"from":"Teaching at the Right Level run by volunteers (India), and older-adult tutoring programmes (United States)","to":"primary schools in low- and middle-income countries, with older adults as the delivery workforce and their own wellbeing as a second outcome"},"mechanism":"Teaching at the Right Level has strong randomised evidence and works with volunteers, not only teachers. Loneliness and isolation are linked to higher mortality in older adults, and school-based older-adult tutoring programmes have been tried in the United States. The proposal joins the two so one programme pays twice: learning for children and purpose and contact for older adults, from a workforce that already exists.","components":["tarl"],"evidence":[{"role":"the teaching method","cite":"Banerjee et al., Journal of Economic Perspectives, 2017","supports":"Randomised evaluations show large gains in basic reading and arithmetic from grouping children by skill, delivered at scale including by volunteers.","doi":"10.1257/jep.31.4.73","verified":true},{"role":"non-teachers can deliver it","cite":"Banerjee, Cole, Duflo and Linden, Quarterly Journal of Economics, 2007","supports":"Young women from the community, hired cheaply as tutors, raised test scores in randomised trials in two Indian cities.","doi":"10.1162/qjec.122.3.1235","verified":true},{"role":"older adults tutoring children","cite":"Rebok et al., Journal of Urban Health, 2004","supports":"Pilot randomised trial of older volunteers in elementary schools in Baltimore: effects on children and schools.","doi":"10.1093/jurban/jth095","verified":true},{"role":"why the older adults' side matters","cite":"Holt-Lunstad et al., Perspectives on Psychological Science, 2015","supports":"Meta-analysis: loneliness, social isolation and living alone were each linked to higher mortality (26%, 29% and 32% higher odds).","doi":"10.1177/1745691614568352","verified":true}],"closest_prior_work":[{"label":"older adult volunteers delivering foundational learning in low-income countries","total":534,"closest":[{"title":"Literacy and numeracy support for homeless adults","year":2018,"url":"https://doi.org/10.17635/lancaster/thesis/272","hit":false},{"title":"Prisoners’ Experiences of Foundation Skills – an Intensive Adult Literacy and Numeracy Programme Delivered in New Zealand Prisons","year":2014,"url":"https://doi.org/10.26686/wgtn.17007358.v1","hit":false},{"title":"Supporting english literacy and numeracy learning for Indigenous students in the early years","year":2003,"url":"https://openalex.org/W2156824084","hit":false},{"title":"The impact of adult literacy and numeracy on small businesses in rural Lincolnshire and Rutland: a case study","year":2004,"url":"https://openalex.org/W2101503942","hit":false},{"title":"Perceptions of how literacy and numeracy instructions influence the lives of adult learners: a qualitative multiple case study of learners with low literacy skills","year":2019,"url":"https://doi.org/10.17918/00000102","hit":false}],"possible_prior_work":false},{"label":"Teaching at the Right Level and older volunteers","total":37357,"closest":[{"title":"Self-growth, wellbeing and volunteering - Implications for social prescribing: A qualitative study","year":2022,"url":"https://doi.org/10.1016/j.ssmqr.2022.100061","hit":false},{"title":"Organisational volunteering: Meanings of volunteering, professionalism, volunteer communities of practice and wellbeing","year":2012,"url":"https://openalex.org/W118528062","hit":false},{"title":"What is the effect of intergenerational activities on the wellbeing and mental health of older people?: A systematic review","year":2023,"url":"https://doi.org/10.1002/cl2.1355","hit":true},{"title":"Qualitative exploration of the impact of employment and volunteering upon the health and wellbeing of African refugees settled in regional Australia: a refugee perspective","year":2019,"url":"https://doi.org/10.1186/s12889-018-6328-2","hit":false},{"title":"Older women: Employment and wellbeing in later life","year":2017,"url":"https://openalex.org/W2772598573","hit":true}],"possible_prior_work":true}],"benefit_cost":{"metric":"WELLBY per USD 1,000","per_1000_usd":{"n":3000,"mean":0.6402446814102695,"p5":0.1831351037103978,"p25":0.3579540707274921,"p50":0.5583579641289858,"p75":0.8289665841693603,"p95":1.3728225335622093},"cost_per_daly":null,"evidence_share":{"A":0,"B":0,"C":0,"D":1},"prob_net_positive":1,"cost_assumption":"USD 20,000 for 100 tutors for one year: stipends of about USD 150, training and materials (assumption)."},"first_test":"30 schools in one district, 10 with older-adult tutors, 10 with standard Teaching at the Right Level tutors, 10 with no programme. Outcomes at one term: children's reading and arithmetic scores, and the older adults' life-satisfaction score before and after (compared with older adults on a waiting list). Stop rule: the pilot fails if children's scores are not higher than with standard tutors, or older adults' life satisfaction does not rise more than the waiting list's.","who":"Primary-school heads, education departments, ageing and social-protection agencies, Pratham-style NGOs.","takes":"Recruit retired people, a two-day training in the Teaching at the Right Level routine, a daily hour of protected class time, a stipend or small incentive, and a baseline and end-line test for the children plus a short wellbeing question for the older adults.","risks":["Recruitment could draw only the already well-connected older adults, missing the isolated ones the loneliness half is for.","Protected class time is hard to keep.","Older adults may be unable to sustain a daily hour; a rota of two people per class is the planned answer."],"limits":"Older adults in some settings are carers or workers with no spare hours, and a low stipend can crowd out the purpose that helps their wellbeing. The learning gain is not converted to WELLBYs here, so the estimate leaves out the larger benefit and is deliberately conservative.","verified_at":"2026-11-18T15:20:09.139Z","url":"https://tenant-ps-web.ultrastable.workers.dev/syntheses/elder-teaching-at-the-right-level"}