{"generated":true,"summary":{"total":122,"open":122,"closed":0,"by_region_status":{"known_unknown:open":95,"ignorance_about_ignorance:open":1,"unknown_unknown:open":26},"by_kind_open":{"untested_assumption":38,"evidence_gap":18,"contradiction":5,"estimate_gap":20,"unexplored_domain":14,"audit_coverage":1,"red_team":14,"inversion":8,"premortem":4},"oldest_open_days":0,"challenged_subjects":4},"accounting":{"entered":122,"open":122,"closed":0,"balanced":true},"last_run":{"at":"2026-11-17 15:33:46","metrics":{"opened":122,"reopened":0,"closed":0,"open":122,"challenged_share":0.10526315789473684,"subjects":38,"targets":["air","birthreg","cash","chlorine"],"stagnant":false,"expansion":122,"audit":{"entered":122,"open":122,"closed":0,"balanced":true}}},"frontier":[{"id":"q:contradiction:clean-cooking:mixed-verdict-pf639h","type":"question","text":"The studies behind \"Clean-fuel stoves (the largest trial found no clear pneumonia benefit)\" disagree. What explains it (population, dose, delivery, period)?","seed":"contradiction:clean-cooking:mixed-verdict-pf639h","priority":4},{"id":"q:contradiction:deworming:mixed-verdict-1gb4s0n","type":"question","text":"The studies behind \"School-based deworming (evidence is contested)\" disagree. What explains it (population, dose, delivery, period)?","seed":"contradiction:deworming:mixed-verdict-1gb4s0n","priority":4},{"id":"q:contradiction:rural-electrification:mixed-verdict-1411bn7","type":"question","text":"The studies behind \"Subsidise grid connections for rural households (benefits are smaller than hoped)\" disagree. What explains it (population, dose, delivery, period)?","seed":"contradiction:rural-electrification:mixed-verdict-1411bn7","priority":4},{"id":"q:unexplored_domain:birthreg:no-solution-k50klc","type":"problem_candidate","text":"No reviewed solution is listed for \"Children whose birth is never registered\". Which interventions have trial or review-level evidence?","seed":"unexplored_domain:birthreg:no-solution-k50klc","priority":4},{"id":"q:unexplored_domain:internet:no-solution-9wsy9e","type":"problem_candidate","text":"No reviewed solution is listed for \"People offline\". Which interventions have trial or review-level evidence?","seed":"unexplored_domain:internet:no-solution-9wsy9e","priority":4},{"id":"q:unexplored_domain:maternal:no-solution-312gfx","type":"problem_candidate","text":"No reviewed solution is listed for \"Mothers dying in childbirth\". Which interventions have trial or review-level evidence?","seed":"unexplored_domain:maternal:no-solution-312gfx","priority":4},{"id":"q:unexplored_domain:sanitation:no-solution-onpkgz","type":"problem_candidate","text":"No reviewed solution is listed for \"Unsafe sanitation\". Which interventions have trial or review-level evidence?","seed":"unexplored_domain:sanitation:no-solution-onpkgz","priority":4},{"id":"q:unexplored_domain:tb:no-solution-tqhdhb","type":"problem_candidate","text":"No reviewed solution is listed for \"Tuberculosis\". Which interventions have trial or review-level evidence?","seed":"unexplored_domain:tb:no-solution-tqhdhb","priority":4},{"id":"q:contradiction:air:verdicts-differ-8kbgxf","type":"question","text":"For problem air, A regulated pollution market with continuous monitoring work(s) while Clean-fuel stoves (the largest trial found no clear pneumonia benefit) show(s) mixed or no effect. Is the difference real or an artefact of context?","seed":"contradiction:air:verdicts-differ-8kbgxf","priority":3},{"id":"q:contradiction:education:verdicts-differ-1x03wb7","type":"question","text":"For problem education, Teaching at the Right Level: group by skill, not grade work(s) while School-based deworming (evidence is contested) show(s) mixed or no effect. Is the difference real or an artefact of context?","seed":"contradiction:education:verdicts-differ-1x03wb7","priority":3},{"id":"q:unexplored_domain:finance:weak-only-eiujl9","type":"problem_candidate","text":"Every solution listed for \"Adults without a financial account\" rests on weak designs. What does the strongest evidence say?","seed":"unexplored_domain:finance:weak-only-eiujl9","priority":3},{"id":"q:unexplored_domain:ncd:weak-only-1yib99q","type":"problem_candidate","text":"Every solution listed for \"Early death from heart disease, cancer, diabetes and lung disease\" rests on weak designs. What does the strongest evidence say?","seed":"unexplored_domain:ncd:weak-only-1yib99q","priority":3},{"id":"q:estimate_gap:cash:no-estimate-1wr4nr1","type":"question","text":"No quantified effect is recorded for \"Give unconditional cash directly to poor households\" in a common unit.","seed":"estimate_gap:cash:no-estimate-1wr4nr1","priority":2},{"id":"q:estimate_gap:chlorine:counterfactual-sc12z0","type":"question","text":"What would have happened without \"Chlorinate water at the point where people collect it\" is not stated for the estimate.","seed":"estimate_gap:chlorine:counterfactual-sc12z0","priority":2},{"id":"q:estimate_gap:chlorine:wide-interval-1a8ycbr","type":"question","text":"The interval for \"Chlorinate water at the point where people collect it\" spans more than threefold (13.273285157065985 to 104.18318858417182 WELLBYs per USD 1,000). A point estimate would mislead.","seed":"estimate_gap:chlorine:wide-interval-1a8ycbr","priority":2},{"id":"q:estimate_gap:clean-cooking:no-estimate-1k3b7dk","type":"question","text":"No quantified effect is recorded for \"Clean-fuel stoves (the largest trial found no clear pneumonia benefit)\" in a common unit.","seed":"estimate_gap:clean-cooking:no-estimate-1k3b7dk","priority":2},{"id":"q:estimate_gap:deworming:no-estimate-9q0o6i","type":"question","text":"No quantified effect is recorded for \"School-based deworming (evidence is contested)\" in a common unit.","seed":"estimate_gap:deworming:no-estimate-9q0o6i","priority":2},{"id":"q:estimate_gap:emissions-market:no-estimate-tjaah5","type":"question","text":"No quantified effect is recorded for \"A regulated pollution market with continuous monitoring\" in a common unit.","seed":"estimate_gap:emissions-market:no-estimate-tjaah5","priority":2},{"id":"q:estimate_gap:friendship-bench:no-estimate-1aivtpz","type":"question","text":"No quantified effect is recorded for \"Lay health workers deliver problem-solving therapy on a bench\" in a common unit.","seed":"estimate_gap:friendship-bench:no-estimate-1aivtpz","priority":2},{"id":"q:estimate_gap:graduation:no-estimate-1lln4q4","type":"question","text":"No quantified effect is recorded for \"The graduation approach: a bundle of an asset, training, savings and coaching\" in a common unit.","seed":"estimate_gap:graduation:no-estimate-1lln4q4","priority":2},{"id":"q:estimate_gap:helmets:no-estimate-5vwals","type":"question","text":"No quantified effect is recorded for \"Require and enforce motorcycle helmets\" in a common unit.","seed":"estimate_gap:helmets:no-estimate-5vwals","priority":2},{"id":"q:estimate_gap:hypertension:no-estimate-1egfuti","type":"question","text":"No quantified effect is recorded for \"Treat high blood pressure with one standard protocol\" in a common unit.","seed":"estimate_gap:hypertension:no-estimate-1egfuti","priority":2},{"id":"q:estimate_gap:immunisation:no-estimate-1xr9y7v","type":"question","text":"No quantified effect is recorded for \"Reliable immunisation camps with a small incentive\" in a common unit.","seed":"estimate_gap:immunisation:no-estimate-1xr9y7v","priority":2},{"id":"q:estimate_gap:itn:no-estimate-8bzzop","type":"question","text":"No quantified effect is recorded for \"Distribute insecticide-treated bed nets, choosing nets that beat local resistance\" in a common unit.","seed":"estimate_gap:itn:no-estimate-8bzzop","priority":2},{"id":"q:estimate_gap:kmc:no-estimate-lrwvsp","type":"question","text":"No quantified effect is recorded for \"Start kangaroo mother care at birth for small babies\" in a common unit.","seed":"estimate_gap:kmc:no-estimate-lrwvsp","priority":2}],"entries":{"clean-cooking":{"challenged_at":null,"open":[{"id":"contradiction:clean-cooking:mixed-verdict-pf639h","kind":"contradiction","region":"known_unknown","text":"The studies behind \"Clean-fuel stoves (the largest trial found no clear pneumonia benefit)\" disagree. What explains it (population, dose, delivery, period)?","severity":3,"how":"Find the effect modifier.","falsifier":null,"source":"rule","opened_at":"2026-11-17 15:33:47","status":"open","disposition":null,"evidence":null},{"id":"estimate_gap:clean-cooking:no-estimate-1k3b7dk","kind":"estimate_gap","region":"known_unknown","text":"No quantified effect is recorded for \"Clean-fuel stoves (the largest trial found no clear pneumonia benefit)\" in a common unit.","severity":2,"how":"Extract the effect size with its interval, or say why it cannot be.","falsifier":null,"source":"rule","opened_at":"2026-11-17 15:33:47","status":"open","disposition":null,"evidence":null},{"id":"evidence_gap:clean-cooking:single-source-ht8epl","kind":"evidence_gap","region":"known_unknown","text":"\"Clean-fuel stoves (the largest trial found no clear pneumonia benefit)\" rests on one source. Has it been replicated independently?","severity":2,"how":"Search for an independent replication.","falsifier":null,"source":"rule","opened_at":"2026-11-17 15:33:47","status":"open","disposition":null,"evidence":null},{"id":"untested_assumption:clean-cooking:assumptions-not-stated-1jc7mj7","kind":"untested_assumption","region":"known_unknown","text":"No assumptions are stated for \"Clean-fuel stoves (the largest trial found no clear pneumonia benefit)\". Every claim rests on some (who it was tested on, who delivers it, what already exists). Which are they, and which were tested?","severity":2,"how":"List the assumptions; mark each tested or untested.","falsifier":null,"source":"rule","opened_at":"2026-11-17 15:33:47","status":"open","disposition":null,"evidence":null}],"closed":[]},"deworming":{"challenged_at":null,"open":[{"id":"contradiction:deworming:mixed-verdict-1gb4s0n","kind":"contradiction","region":"known_unknown","text":"The studies behind \"School-based deworming (evidence is contested)\" disagree. What explains it (population, dose, delivery, period)?","severity":3,"how":"Find the effect modifier.","falsifier":null,"source":"rule","opened_at":"2026-11-17 15:33:47","status":"open","disposition":null,"evidence":null},{"id":"estimate_gap:deworming:no-estimate-9q0o6i","kind":"estimate_gap","region":"known_unknown","text":"No quantified effect is recorded for \"School-based deworming (evidence is contested)\" in a common unit.","severity":2,"how":"Extract the effect size with its interval, or say why it cannot be.","falsifier":null,"source":"rule","opened_at":"2026-11-17 15:33:47","status":"open","disposition":null,"evidence":null},{"id":"untested_assumption:deworming:assumptions-not-stated-1wn1s9x","kind":"untested_assumption","region":"known_unknown","text":"No assumptions are stated for \"School-based deworming (evidence is contested)\". Every claim rests on some (who it was tested on, who delivers it, what already exists). Which are they, and which were tested?","severity":2,"how":"List the assumptions; mark each tested or untested.","falsifier":null,"source":"rule","opened_at":"2026-11-17 15:33:47","status":"open","disposition":null,"evidence":null}],"closed":[]},"rural-electrification":{"challenged_at":null,"open":[{"id":"contradiction:rural-electrification:mixed-verdict-1411bn7","kind":"contradiction","region":"known_unknown","text":"The studies behind \"Subsidise grid connections for rural households (benefits are smaller than hoped)\" disagree. What explains it (population, dose, delivery, period)?","severity":3,"how":"Find the effect modifier.","falsifier":null,"source":"rule","opened_at":"2026-11-17 15:33:47","status":"open","disposition":null,"evidence":null},{"id":"estimate_gap:rural-electrification:no-estimate-1pteojq","kind":"estimate_gap","region":"known_unknown","text":"No quantified effect is recorded for \"Subsidise grid connections for rural households (benefits are smaller than hoped)\" in a common unit.","severity":2,"how":"Extract the effect size with its interval, or say why it cannot be.","falsifier":null,"source":"rule","opened_at":"2026-11-17 15:33:47","status":"open","disposition":null,"evidence":null},{"id":"evidence_gap:rural-electrification:single-source-bm8l9j","kind":"evidence_gap","region":"known_unknown","text":"\"Subsidise grid connections for rural households (benefits are smaller than hoped)\" rests on one source. Has it been replicated independently?","severity":2,"how":"Search for an independent replication.","falsifier":null,"source":"rule","opened_at":"2026-11-17 15:33:47","status":"open","disposition":null,"evidence":null},{"id":"untested_assumption:rural-electrification:assumptions-not-stated-1ry4u69","kind":"untested_assumption","region":"known_unknown","text":"No assumptions are stated for \"Subsidise grid connections for rural households (benefits are smaller than hoped)\". Every claim rests on some (who it was tested on, who delivers it, what already exists). Which are they, and which were tested?","severity":2,"how":"List the assumptions; mark each tested or untested.","falsifier":null,"source":"rule","opened_at":"2026-11-17 15:33:47","status":"open","disposition":null,"evidence":null}],"closed":[]},"birthreg":{"challenged_at":"2026-11-17 15:33:46","open":[{"id":"unexplored_domain:birthreg:no-solution-k50klc","kind":"unexplored_domain","region":"known_unknown","text":"No reviewed solution is listed for \"Children whose birth is never registered\". Which interventions have trial or review-level evidence?","severity":3,"how":"Search the literature; list candidates as leads.","falsifier":null,"source":"rule","opened_at":"2026-11-17 15:33:47","status":"open","disposition":null,"evidence":null},{"id":"inversion:birthreg:imagine-a-world-where-ch-2wu6n7","kind":"inversion","region":"unknown_unknown","text":"Imagine a world where \"Children whose birth is never registered\" is false. What would we see there that we do not see here?","severity":2,"how":"test the opposite or record why it fails","falsifier":"Evidence that those observations exist.","source":"rule","opened_at":"2026-11-17 15:33:47","status":"open","disposition":null,"evidence":null},{"id":"inversion:birthreg:what-if-the-opposite-of--1ne0zb9","kind":"inversion","region":"unknown_unknown","text":"What if the opposite of \"Children whose birth is never registered\" were better: doing nothing, or acting upstream of the problem? Under what conditions would that win?","severity":2,"how":"test the opposite or record why it fails","falsifier":"A head-to-head comparison against the opposite.","source":"rule","opened_at":"2026-11-17 15:33:47","status":"open","disposition":null,"evidence":null},{"id":"premortem:birthreg:two-years-on-the-first-t-7zvqr8","kind":"premortem","region":"unknown_unknown","text":"Two years on, the first test of \"Children whose birth is never registered\" failed. The three likeliest reasons: adoption stalled, the effect did not transfer, measurement could not detect it. Which has any check today?","severity":2,"how":"add a check for the failure story or accept the risk","falsifier":"A pilot that fails for one of those reasons.","source":"rule","opened_at":"2026-11-17 15:33:47","status":"open","disposition":null,"evidence":null},{"id":"red_team:birthreg:what-does-children-whose-bjsw4n","kind":"red_team","region":"unknown_unknown","text":"What does \"Children whose birth is never registered\" quietly assume about who delivers it and what already exists? No deliverer is named.","severity":2,"how":"answer the challenge with evidence or record that it stands","falsifier":"A setting without that delivery channel where it still works.","source":"rule","opened_at":"2026-11-17 15:33:47","status":"open","disposition":null,"evidence":null},{"id":"red_team:birthreg:who-is-worse-off-exclude-1n7rfj5","kind":"red_team","region":"unknown_unknown","text":"Who is worse off, excluded or displaced if \"Children whose birth is never registered\" works? Costs and harms that land on others are not in the claim.","severity":2,"how":"answer the challenge with evidence or record that it stands","falsifier":"A measured harm or displacement effect.","source":"rule","opened_at":"2026-11-17 15:33:47","status":"open","disposition":null,"evidence":null},{"id":"untested_assumption:birthreg:assumptions-not-stated-u56mo","kind":"untested_assumption","region":"known_unknown","text":"No assumptions are stated for \"Children whose birth is never registered\". Every claim rests on some (who it was tested on, who delivers it, what already exists). Which are they, and which were tested?","severity":2,"how":"List the assumptions; mark each tested or untested.","falsifier":null,"source":"rule","opened_at":"2026-11-17 15:33:47","status":"open","disposition":null,"evidence":null},{"id":"red_team:birthreg:would-the-people-who-mus-jdmnfy","kind":"red_team","region":"unknown_unknown","text":"Would the people who must carry out \"Children whose birth is never registered\" describe the cost and effort the same way the evidence does?","severity":1,"how":"answer the challenge with evidence or record that it stands","falsifier":"Implementers reporting a materially larger burden.","source":"rule","opened_at":"2026-11-17 15:33:47","status":"open","disposition":null,"evidence":null}],"closed":[]},"internet":{"challenged_at":null,"open":[{"id":"unexplored_domain:internet:no-solution-9wsy9e","kind":"unexplored_domain","region":"known_unknown","text":"No reviewed solution is listed for \"People offline\". Which interventions have trial or review-level evidence?","severity":3,"how":"Search the literature; list candidates as leads.","falsifier":null,"source":"rule","opened_at":"2026-11-17 15:33:47","status":"open","disposition":null,"evidence":null},{"id":"untested_assumption:internet:assumptions-not-stated-1622nr6","kind":"untested_assumption","region":"known_unknown","text":"No assumptions are stated for \"People offline\". Every claim rests on some (who it was tested on, who delivers it, what already exists). Which are they, and which were tested?","severity":2,"how":"List the assumptions; mark each tested or untested.","falsifier":null,"source":"rule","opened_at":"2026-11-17 15:33:47","status":"open","disposition":null,"evidence":null}],"closed":[]},"maternal":{"challenged_at":null,"open":[{"id":"unexplored_domain:maternal:no-solution-312gfx","kind":"unexplored_domain","region":"known_unknown","text":"No reviewed solution is listed for \"Mothers dying in childbirth\". Which interventions have trial or review-level evidence?","severity":3,"how":"Search the literature; list candidates as leads.","falsifier":null,"source":"rule","opened_at":"2026-11-17 15:33:47","status":"open","disposition":null,"evidence":null},{"id":"untested_assumption:maternal:assumptions-not-stated-18qii3x","kind":"untested_assumption","region":"known_unknown","text":"No assumptions are stated for \"Mothers dying in childbirth\". Every claim rests on some (who it was tested on, who delivers it, what already exists). Which are they, and which were tested?","severity":2,"how":"List the assumptions; mark each tested or untested.","falsifier":null,"source":"rule","opened_at":"2026-11-17 15:33:47","status":"open","disposition":null,"evidence":null}],"closed":[]},"sanitation":{"challenged_at":null,"open":[{"id":"unexplored_domain:sanitation:no-solution-onpkgz","kind":"unexplored_domain","region":"known_unknown","text":"No reviewed solution is listed for \"Unsafe sanitation\". Which interventions have trial or review-level evidence?","severity":3,"how":"Search the literature; list candidates as leads.","falsifier":null,"source":"rule","opened_at":"2026-11-17 15:33:47","status":"open","disposition":null,"evidence":null},{"id":"untested_assumption:sanitation:assumptions-not-stated-yc9043","kind":"untested_assumption","region":"known_unknown","text":"No assumptions are stated for \"Unsafe sanitation\". Every claim rests on some (who it was tested on, who delivers it, what already exists). Which are they, and which were tested?","severity":2,"how":"List the assumptions; mark each tested or untested.","falsifier":null,"source":"rule","opened_at":"2026-11-17 15:33:47","status":"open","disposition":null,"evidence":null}],"closed":[]},"tb":{"challenged_at":null,"open":[{"id":"unexplored_domain:tb:no-solution-tqhdhb","kind":"unexplored_domain","region":"known_unknown","text":"No reviewed solution is listed for \"Tuberculosis\". Which interventions have trial or review-level evidence?","severity":3,"how":"Search the literature; list candidates as leads.","falsifier":null,"source":"rule","opened_at":"2026-11-17 15:33:47","status":"open","disposition":null,"evidence":null},{"id":"untested_assumption:tb:assumptions-not-stated-15teodr","kind":"untested_assumption","region":"known_unknown","text":"No assumptions are stated for \"Tuberculosis\". Every claim rests on some (who it was tested on, who delivers it, what already exists). Which are they, and which were tested?","severity":2,"how":"List the assumptions; mark each tested or untested.","falsifier":null,"source":"rule","opened_at":"2026-11-17 15:33:47","status":"open","disposition":null,"evidence":null}],"closed":[]},"air":{"challenged_at":"2026-11-17 15:33:46","open":[{"id":"contradiction:air:verdicts-differ-8kbgxf","kind":"contradiction","region":"known_unknown","text":"For problem air, A regulated pollution market with continuous monitoring work(s) while Clean-fuel stoves (the largest trial found no clear pneumonia benefit) show(s) mixed or no effect. Is the difference real or an artefact of context?","severity":2,"how":"Compare their settings.","falsifier":null,"source":"rule","opened_at":"2026-11-17 15:33:47","status":"open","disposition":null,"evidence":null},{"id":"inversion:air:imagine-a-world-where-po-p02w8r","kind":"inversion","region":"unknown_unknown","text":"Imagine a world where \"Polluted air\" is false. What would we see there that we do not see here?","severity":2,"how":"test the opposite or record why it fails","falsifier":"Evidence that those observations exist.","source":"rule","opened_at":"2026-11-17 15:33:47","status":"open","disposition":null,"evidence":null},{"id":"inversion:air:what-if-the-opposite-of--1neoot9","kind":"inversion","region":"unknown_unknown","text":"What if the opposite of \"Polluted air\" were better: doing nothing, or acting upstream of the problem? Under what conditions would that win?","severity":2,"how":"test the opposite or record why it fails","falsifier":"A head-to-head comparison against the opposite.","source":"rule","opened_at":"2026-11-17 15:33:47","status":"open","disposition":null,"evidence":null},{"id":"premortem:air:two-years-on-the-first-t-1b12w24","kind":"premortem","region":"unknown_unknown","text":"Two years on, the first test of \"Polluted air\" failed. The three likeliest reasons: adoption stalled, the effect did not transfer, measurement could not detect it. Which has any check today?","severity":2,"how":"add a check for the failure story or accept the risk","falsifier":"A pilot that fails for one of those reasons.","source":"rule","opened_at":"2026-11-17 15:33:47","status":"open","disposition":null,"evidence":null},{"id":"red_team:air:what-does-polluted-air-q-203kcf","kind":"red_team","region":"unknown_unknown","text":"What does \"Polluted air\" quietly assume about who delivers it and what already exists? No deliverer is named.","severity":2,"how":"answer the challenge with evidence or record that it stands","falsifier":"A setting without that delivery channel where it still works.","source":"rule","opened_at":"2026-11-17 15:33:47","status":"open","disposition":null,"evidence":null},{"id":"red_team:air:who-is-worse-off-exclude-3bmt95","kind":"red_team","region":"unknown_unknown","text":"Who is worse off, excluded or displaced if \"Polluted air\" works? Costs and harms that land on others are not in the claim.","severity":2,"how":"answer the challenge with evidence or record that it stands","falsifier":"A measured harm or displacement effect.","source":"rule","opened_at":"2026-11-17 15:33:47","status":"open","disposition":null,"evidence":null},{"id":"untested_assumption:air:assumptions-not-stated-xrek2d","kind":"untested_assumption","region":"known_unknown","text":"No assumptions are stated for \"Polluted air\". Every claim rests on some (who it was tested on, who delivers it, what already exists). Which are they, and which were tested?","severity":2,"how":"List the assumptions; mark each tested or untested.","falsifier":null,"source":"rule","opened_at":"2026-11-17 15:33:47","status":"open","disposition":null,"evidence":null},{"id":"red_team:air:would-the-people-who-mus-107gwhy","kind":"red_team","region":"unknown_unknown","text":"Would the people who must carry out \"Polluted air\" describe the cost and effort the same way the evidence does?","severity":1,"how":"answer the challenge with evidence or record that it stands","falsifier":"Implementers reporting a materially larger burden.","source":"rule","opened_at":"2026-11-17 15:33:47","status":"open","disposition":null,"evidence":null}],"closed":[]},"education":{"challenged_at":null,"open":[{"id":"contradiction:education:verdicts-differ-1x03wb7","kind":"contradiction","region":"known_unknown","text":"For problem education, Teaching at the Right Level: group by skill, not grade work(s) while School-based deworming (evidence is contested) show(s) mixed or no effect. Is the difference real or an artefact of context?","severity":2,"how":"Compare their settings.","falsifier":null,"source":"rule","opened_at":"2026-11-17 15:33:47","status":"open","disposition":null,"evidence":null},{"id":"untested_assumption:education:assumptions-not-stated-1a57ph1","kind":"untested_assumption","region":"known_unknown","text":"No assumptions are stated for \"Children not finishing primary school\". Every claim rests on some (who it was tested on, who delivers it, what already exists). Which are they, and which were tested?","severity":2,"how":"List the assumptions; mark each tested or untested.","falsifier":null,"source":"rule","opened_at":"2026-11-17 15:33:47","status":"open","disposition":null,"evidence":null}],"closed":[]},"cash":{"challenged_at":"2026-11-17 15:33:46","open":[{"id":"estimate_gap:cash:no-estimate-1wr4nr1","kind":"estimate_gap","region":"known_unknown","text":"No quantified effect is recorded for \"Give unconditional cash directly to poor households\" in a common unit.","severity":2,"how":"Extract the effect size with its interval, or say why it cannot be.","falsifier":null,"source":"rule","opened_at":"2026-11-17 15:33:47","status":"open","disposition":null,"evidence":null},{"id":"evidence_gap:cash:single-source-1xg0nb2","kind":"evidence_gap","region":"known_unknown","text":"\"Give unconditional cash directly to poor households\" rests on one source. Has it been replicated independently?","severity":2,"how":"Search for an independent replication.","falsifier":null,"source":"rule","opened_at":"2026-11-17 15:33:47","status":"open","disposition":null,"evidence":null},{"id":"inversion:cash:imagine-a-world-where-gi-17p1m63","kind":"inversion","region":"unknown_unknown","text":"Imagine a world where \"Give unconditional cash directly to poor households\" is false. What would we see there that we do not see here?","severity":2,"how":"test the opposite or record why it fails","falsifier":"Evidence that those observations exist.","source":"rule","opened_at":"2026-11-17 15:33:47","status":"open","disposition":null,"evidence":null},{"id":"inversion:cash:what-if-the-opposite-of--80t2l9","kind":"inversion","region":"unknown_unknown","text":"What if the opposite of \"Give unconditional cash directly to poor households\" were better: doing nothing, or acting upstream of the problem? Under what conditions would that win?","severity":2,"how":"test the opposite or record why it fails","falsifier":"A head-to-head comparison against the opposite.","source":"rule","opened_at":"2026-11-17 15:33:47","status":"open","disposition":null,"evidence":null},{"id":"premortem:cash:two-years-on-the-first-t-1inusmk","kind":"premortem","region":"unknown_unknown","text":"Two years on, the first test of \"Give unconditional cash directly to poor households\" failed. The three likeliest reasons: adoption stalled, the effect did not transfer, measurement could not detect it. Which has any check today?","severity":2,"how":"add a check for the failure story or accept the risk","falsifier":"A pilot that fails for one of those reasons.","source":"rule","opened_at":"2026-11-17 15:33:47","status":"open","disposition":null,"evidence":null},{"id":"red_team:cash:the-stated-limit-for-giv-1ninaw3","kind":"red_team","region":"unknown_unknown","text":"The stated limit for \"Give unconditional cash directly to poor households\" is: Effects on long-run income are weaker than on consumption; inflation and targeting errors depend on local markets. What is outside that limit that nobody has tested?","severity":2,"how":"answer the challenge with evidence or record that it stands","falsifier":"Evidence from outside the stated limit.","source":"rule","opened_at":"2026-11-17 15:33:47","status":"open","disposition":null,"evidence":null},{"id":"red_team:cash:what-does-give-unconditi-1afjkt7","kind":"red_team","region":"unknown_unknown","text":"What does \"Give unconditional cash directly to poor households\" quietly assume about who delivers it and what already exists? It names: Social-protection ministries, NGOs and funders..","severity":2,"how":"answer the challenge with evidence or record that it stands","falsifier":"A setting without that delivery channel where it still works.","source":"rule","opened_at":"2026-11-17 15:33:47","status":"open","disposition":null,"evidence":null},{"id":"red_team:cash:who-is-worse-off-exclude-9f3ll","kind":"red_team","region":"unknown_unknown","text":"Who is worse off, excluded or displaced if \"Give unconditional cash directly to poor households\" works? Costs and harms that land on others are not in the claim.","severity":2,"how":"answer the challenge with evidence or record that it stands","falsifier":"A measured harm or displacement effect.","source":"rule","opened_at":"2026-11-17 15:33:47","status":"open","disposition":null,"evidence":null},{"id":"untested_assumption:cash:assumptions-not-stated-1mmz5a0","kind":"untested_assumption","region":"known_unknown","text":"No assumptions are stated for \"Give unconditional cash directly to poor households\". Every claim rests on some (who it was tested on, who delivers it, what already exists). Which are they, and which were tested?","severity":2,"how":"List the assumptions; mark each tested or untested.","falsifier":null,"source":"rule","opened_at":"2026-11-17 15:33:47","status":"open","disposition":null,"evidence":null},{"id":"red_team:cash:would-the-people-who-mus-lnlt2","kind":"red_team","region":"unknown_unknown","text":"Would the people who must carry out \"Give unconditional cash directly to poor households\" describe the cost and effort the same way the evidence does?","severity":1,"how":"answer the challenge with evidence or record that it stands","falsifier":"Implementers reporting a materially larger burden.","source":"rule","opened_at":"2026-11-17 15:33:47","status":"open","disposition":null,"evidence":null}],"closed":[]},"chlorine":{"challenged_at":"2026-11-17 15:33:46","open":[{"id":"estimate_gap:chlorine:counterfactual-sc12z0","kind":"estimate_gap","region":"known_unknown","text":"What would have happened without \"Chlorinate water at the point where people collect it\" is not stated for the estimate.","severity":2,"how":"quantify it or state why it cannot be quantified","falsifier":null,"source":"rule","opened_at":"2026-11-17 15:33:47","status":"open","disposition":null,"evidence":null},{"id":"estimate_gap:chlorine:wide-interval-1a8ycbr","kind":"estimate_gap","region":"known_unknown","text":"The interval for \"Chlorinate water at the point where people collect it\" spans more than threefold (13.273285157065985 to 104.18318858417182 WELLBYs per USD 1,000). A point estimate would mislead.","severity":2,"how":"Carry the whole interval into any ranking.","falsifier":null,"source":"rule","opened_at":"2026-11-17 15:33:47","status":"open","disposition":null,"evidence":null},{"id":"evidence_gap:chlorine:single-source-81r8c3","kind":"evidence_gap","region":"known_unknown","text":"\"Chlorinate water at the point where people collect it\" rests on one source. Has it been replicated independently?","severity":2,"how":"Search for an independent replication.","falsifier":null,"source":"rule","opened_at":"2026-11-17 15:33:47","status":"open","disposition":null,"evidence":null},{"id":"inversion:chlorine:imagine-a-world-where-ch-5cizrx","kind":"inversion","region":"unknown_unknown","text":"Imagine a world where \"Chlorinate water at the point where people collect it\" is false. What would we see there that we do not see here?","severity":2,"how":"test the opposite or record why it fails","falsifier":"Evidence that those observations exist.","source":"rule","opened_at":"2026-11-17 15:33:47","status":"open","disposition":null,"evidence":null},{"id":"inversion:chlorine:what-if-the-opposite-of--lx3bun","kind":"inversion","region":"unknown_unknown","text":"What if the opposite of \"Chlorinate water at the point where people collect it\" were better: doing nothing, or acting upstream of the problem? Under what conditions would that win?","severity":2,"how":"test the opposite or record why it fails","falsifier":"A head-to-head comparison against the opposite.","source":"rule","opened_at":"2026-11-17 15:33:47","status":"open","disposition":null,"evidence":null},{"id":"premortem:chlorine:two-years-on-the-first-t-1rqm3im","kind":"premortem","region":"unknown_unknown","text":"Two years on, the first test of \"Chlorinate water at the point where people collect it\" failed. The three likeliest reasons: adoption stalled, the effect did not transfer, measurement could not detect it. Which has any check today?","severity":2,"how":"add a check for the failure story or accept the risk","falsifier":"A pilot that fails for one of those reasons.","source":"rule","opened_at":"2026-11-17 15:33:47","status":"open","disposition":null,"evidence":null},{"id":"red_team:chlorine:the-stated-limit-for-chl-1honqeq","kind":"red_team","region":"unknown_unknown","text":"The stated limit for \"Chlorinate water at the point where people collect it\" is: Effect depends on people using the dispensers; works poorly where households already treat water or sources are piped and treated. What is outside that limit that nobody has tested?","severity":2,"how":"answer the challenge with evidence or record that it stands","falsifier":"Evidence from outside the stated limit.","source":"rule","opened_at":"2026-11-17 15:33:47","status":"open","disposition":null,"evidence":null},{"id":"red_team:chlorine:what-does-chlorinate-wat-nuid7","kind":"red_team","region":"unknown_unknown","text":"What does \"Chlorinate water at the point where people collect it\" quietly assume about who delivers it and what already exists? It names: Water authorities, NGOs, village committees..","severity":2,"how":"answer the challenge with evidence or record that it stands","falsifier":"A setting without that delivery channel where it still works.","source":"rule","opened_at":"2026-11-17 15:33:47","status":"open","disposition":null,"evidence":null},{"id":"red_team:chlorine:who-is-worse-off-exclude-lhnznf","kind":"red_team","region":"unknown_unknown","text":"Who is worse off, excluded or displaced if \"Chlorinate water at the point where people collect it\" works? Costs and harms that land on others are not in the claim.","severity":2,"how":"answer the challenge with evidence or record that it stands","falsifier":"A measured harm or displacement effect.","source":"rule","opened_at":"2026-11-17 15:33:47","status":"open","disposition":null,"evidence":null},{"id":"untested_assumption:chlorine:assumptions-not-stated-1nbcg0d","kind":"untested_assumption","region":"known_unknown","text":"No assumptions are stated for \"Chlorinate water at the point where people collect it\". Every claim rests on some (who it was tested on, who delivers it, what already exists). Which are they, and which were tested?","severity":2,"how":"List the assumptions; mark each tested or untested.","falsifier":null,"source":"rule","opened_at":"2026-11-17 15:33:47","status":"open","disposition":null,"evidence":null},{"id":"estimate_gap:chlorine:top-driver-w79q2g","kind":"estimate_gap","region":"known_unknown","text":"The estimate for \"Chlorinate water at the point where people collect it\" is most sensitive to \"dalys\". A better measurement of it narrows the answer most.","severity":1,"how":"Look for a direct measurement of that input.","falsifier":null,"source":"rule","opened_at":"2026-11-17 15:33:47","status":"open","disposition":null,"evidence":null},{"id":"red_team:chlorine:would-the-people-who-mus-12boqbs","kind":"red_team","region":"unknown_unknown","text":"Would the people who must carry out \"Chlorinate water at the point where people collect it\" describe the cost and effort the same way the evidence does?","severity":1,"how":"answer the challenge with evidence or record that it stands","falsifier":"Implementers reporting a materially larger burden.","source":"rule","opened_at":"2026-11-17 15:33:47","status":"open","disposition":null,"evidence":null}],"closed":[]},"emissions-market":{"challenged_at":null,"open":[{"id":"estimate_gap:emissions-market:no-estimate-tjaah5","kind":"estimate_gap","region":"known_unknown","text":"No quantified effect is recorded for \"A regulated pollution market with continuous monitoring\" in a common unit.","severity":2,"how":"Extract the effect size with its interval, or say why it cannot be.","falsifier":null,"source":"rule","opened_at":"2026-11-17 15:33:47","status":"open","disposition":null,"evidence":null},{"id":"evidence_gap:emissions-market:single-source-kecn2i","kind":"evidence_gap","region":"known_unknown","text":"\"A regulated pollution market with continuous monitoring\" rests on one source. Has it been replicated independently?","severity":2,"how":"Search for an independent replication.","falsifier":null,"source":"rule","opened_at":"2026-11-17 15:33:47","status":"open","disposition":null,"evidence":null},{"id":"untested_assumption:emissions-market:assumptions-not-stated-c98e6c","kind":"untested_assumption","region":"known_unknown","text":"No assumptions are stated for \"A regulated pollution market with continuous monitoring\". Every claim rests on some (who it was tested on, who delivers it, what already exists). Which are they, and which were tested?","severity":2,"how":"List the assumptions; mark each tested or untested.","falsifier":null,"source":"rule","opened_at":"2026-11-17 15:33:47","status":"open","disposition":null,"evidence":null}],"closed":[]},"friendship-bench":{"challenged_at":null,"open":[{"id":"estimate_gap:friendship-bench:no-estimate-1aivtpz","kind":"estimate_gap","region":"known_unknown","text":"No quantified effect is recorded for \"Lay health workers deliver problem-solving therapy on a bench\" in a common unit.","severity":2,"how":"Extract the effect size with its interval, or say why it cannot be.","falsifier":null,"source":"rule","opened_at":"2026-11-17 15:33:47","status":"open","disposition":null,"evidence":null},{"id":"evidence_gap:friendship-bench:single-source-1h7hjp4","kind":"evidence_gap","region":"known_unknown","text":"\"Lay health workers deliver problem-solving therapy on a bench\" rests on one source. Has it been replicated independently?","severity":2,"how":"Search for an independent replication.","falsifier":null,"source":"rule","opened_at":"2026-11-17 15:33:47","status":"open","disposition":null,"evidence":null},{"id":"untested_assumption:friendship-bench:assumptions-not-stated-ihnkqa","kind":"untested_assumption","region":"known_unknown","text":"No assumptions are stated for \"Lay health workers deliver problem-solving therapy on a bench\". Every claim rests on some (who it was tested on, who delivers it, what already exists). Which are they, and which were tested?","severity":2,"how":"List the assumptions; mark each tested or untested.","falsifier":null,"source":"rule","opened_at":"2026-11-17 15:33:47","status":"open","disposition":null,"evidence":null}],"closed":[]},"graduation":{"challenged_at":null,"open":[{"id":"estimate_gap:graduation:no-estimate-1lln4q4","kind":"estimate_gap","region":"known_unknown","text":"No quantified effect is recorded for \"The graduation approach: a bundle of an asset, training, savings and coaching\" in a common unit.","severity":2,"how":"Extract the effect size with its interval, or say why it cannot be.","falsifier":null,"source":"rule","opened_at":"2026-11-17 15:33:47","status":"open","disposition":null,"evidence":null},{"id":"evidence_gap:graduation:single-source-108n1il","kind":"evidence_gap","region":"known_unknown","text":"\"The graduation approach: a bundle of an asset, training, savings and coaching\" rests on one source. Has it been replicated independently?","severity":2,"how":"Search for an independent replication.","falsifier":null,"source":"rule","opened_at":"2026-11-17 15:33:47","status":"open","disposition":null,"evidence":null},{"id":"untested_assumption:graduation:assumptions-not-stated-1oy75c7","kind":"untested_assumption","region":"known_unknown","text":"No assumptions are stated for \"The graduation approach: a bundle of an asset, training, savings and coaching\". Every claim rests on some (who it was tested on, who delivers it, what already exists). Which are they, and which were tested?","severity":2,"how":"List the assumptions; mark each tested or untested.","falsifier":null,"source":"rule","opened_at":"2026-11-17 15:33:47","status":"open","disposition":null,"evidence":null}],"closed":[]},"helmets":{"challenged_at":null,"open":[{"id":"estimate_gap:helmets:no-estimate-5vwals","kind":"estimate_gap","region":"known_unknown","text":"No quantified effect is recorded for \"Require and enforce motorcycle helmets\" in a common unit.","severity":2,"how":"Extract the effect size with its interval, or say why it cannot be.","falsifier":null,"source":"rule","opened_at":"2026-11-17 15:33:47","status":"open","disposition":null,"evidence":null},{"id":"evidence_gap:helmets:single-source-1tdrbv5","kind":"evidence_gap","region":"known_unknown","text":"\"Require and enforce motorcycle helmets\" rests on one source. Has it been replicated independently?","severity":2,"how":"Search for an independent replication.","falsifier":null,"source":"rule","opened_at":"2026-11-17 15:33:47","status":"open","disposition":null,"evidence":null},{"id":"untested_assumption:helmets:assumptions-not-stated-4s1xyj","kind":"untested_assumption","region":"known_unknown","text":"No assumptions are stated for \"Require and enforce motorcycle helmets\". Every claim rests on some (who it was tested on, who delivers it, what already exists). Which are they, and which were tested?","severity":2,"how":"List the assumptions; mark each tested or untested.","falsifier":null,"source":"rule","opened_at":"2026-11-17 15:33:47","status":"open","disposition":null,"evidence":null}],"closed":[]},"hypertension":{"challenged_at":null,"open":[{"id":"estimate_gap:hypertension:no-estimate-1egfuti","kind":"estimate_gap","region":"known_unknown","text":"No quantified effect is recorded for \"Treat high blood pressure with one standard protocol\" in a common unit.","severity":2,"how":"Extract the effect size with its interval, or say why it cannot be.","falsifier":null,"source":"rule","opened_at":"2026-11-17 15:33:47","status":"open","disposition":null,"evidence":null},{"id":"evidence_gap:hypertension:single-source-b52p53","kind":"evidence_gap","region":"known_unknown","text":"\"Treat high blood pressure with one standard protocol\" rests on one source. Has it been replicated independently?","severity":2,"how":"Search for an independent replication.","falsifier":null,"source":"rule","opened_at":"2026-11-17 15:33:47","status":"open","disposition":null,"evidence":null},{"id":"evidence_gap:hypertension:weak-design-pyyf86","kind":"evidence_gap","region":"known_unknown","text":"The strongest design cited for \"Treat high blood pressure with one standard protocol\" is observational, which cannot rule out confounding. Is there a trial or review?","severity":2,"how":"Search for a randomised trial or systematic review.","falsifier":null,"source":"rule","opened_at":"2026-11-17 15:33:47","status":"open","disposition":null,"evidence":null},{"id":"untested_assumption:hypertension:assumptions-not-stated-3bjp0h","kind":"untested_assumption","region":"known_unknown","text":"No assumptions are stated for \"Treat high blood pressure with one standard protocol\". Every claim rests on some (who it was tested on, who delivers it, what already exists). Which are they, and which were tested?","severity":2,"how":"List the assumptions; mark each tested or untested.","falsifier":null,"source":"rule","opened_at":"2026-11-17 15:33:47","status":"open","disposition":null,"evidence":null}],"closed":[]},"immunisation":{"challenged_at":null,"open":[{"id":"estimate_gap:immunisation:no-estimate-1xr9y7v","kind":"estimate_gap","region":"known_unknown","text":"No quantified effect is recorded for \"Reliable immunisation camps with a small incentive\" in a common unit.","severity":2,"how":"Extract the effect size with its interval, or say why it cannot be.","falsifier":null,"source":"rule","opened_at":"2026-11-17 15:33:47","status":"open","disposition":null,"evidence":null},{"id":"evidence_gap:immunisation:single-source-4s39vg","kind":"evidence_gap","region":"known_unknown","text":"\"Reliable immunisation camps with a small incentive\" rests on one source. Has it been replicated independently?","severity":2,"how":"Search for an independent replication.","falsifier":null,"source":"rule","opened_at":"2026-11-17 15:33:47","status":"open","disposition":null,"evidence":null},{"id":"untested_assumption:immunisation:assumptions-not-stated-1lc7nqu","kind":"untested_assumption","region":"known_unknown","text":"No assumptions are stated for \"Reliable immunisation camps with a small incentive\". Every claim rests on some (who it was tested on, who delivers it, what already exists). Which are they, and which were tested?","severity":2,"how":"List the assumptions; mark each tested or untested.","falsifier":null,"source":"rule","opened_at":"2026-11-17 15:33:47","status":"open","disposition":null,"evidence":null}],"closed":[]},"itn":{"challenged_at":null,"open":[{"id":"estimate_gap:itn:no-estimate-8bzzop","kind":"estimate_gap","region":"known_unknown","text":"No quantified effect is recorded for \"Distribute insecticide-treated bed nets, choosing nets that beat local resistance\" in a common unit.","severity":2,"how":"Extract the effect size with its interval, or say why it cannot be.","falsifier":null,"source":"rule","opened_at":"2026-11-17 15:33:47","status":"open","disposition":null,"evidence":null},{"id":"untested_assumption:itn:assumptions-not-stated-17qje84","kind":"untested_assumption","region":"known_unknown","text":"No assumptions are stated for \"Distribute insecticide-treated bed nets, choosing nets that beat local resistance\". Every claim rests on some (who it was tested on, who delivers it, what already exists). Which are they, and which were tested?","severity":2,"how":"List the assumptions; mark each tested or untested.","falsifier":null,"source":"rule","opened_at":"2026-11-17 15:33:47","status":"open","disposition":null,"evidence":null}],"closed":[]},"kmc":{"challenged_at":null,"open":[{"id":"estimate_gap:kmc:no-estimate-lrwvsp","kind":"estimate_gap","region":"known_unknown","text":"No quantified effect is recorded for \"Start kangaroo mother care at birth for small babies\" in a common unit.","severity":2,"how":"Extract the effect size with its interval, or say why it cannot be.","falsifier":null,"source":"rule","opened_at":"2026-11-17 15:33:47","status":"open","disposition":null,"evidence":null},{"id":"evidence_gap:kmc:single-source-44eoka","kind":"evidence_gap","region":"known_unknown","text":"\"Start kangaroo mother care at birth for small babies\" rests on one source. Has it been replicated independently?","severity":2,"how":"Search for an independent replication.","falsifier":null,"source":"rule","opened_at":"2026-11-17 15:33:47","status":"open","disposition":null,"evidence":null},{"id":"untested_assumption:kmc:assumptions-not-stated-1dpbh3o","kind":"untested_assumption","region":"known_unknown","text":"No assumptions are stated for \"Start kangaroo mother care at birth for small babies\". Every claim rests on some (who it was tested on, who delivers it, what already exists). Which are they, and which were tested?","severity":2,"how":"List the assumptions; mark each tested or untested.","falsifier":null,"source":"rule","opened_at":"2026-11-17 15:33:47","status":"open","disposition":null,"evidence":null}],"closed":[]},"mobile-money":{"challenged_at":null,"open":[{"id":"estimate_gap:mobile-money:no-estimate-h3yycr","kind":"estimate_gap","region":"known_unknown","text":"No quantified effect is recorded for \"Mobile money agent networks\" in a common unit.","severity":2,"how":"Extract the effect size with its interval, or say why it cannot be.","falsifier":null,"source":"rule","opened_at":"2026-11-17 15:33:47","status":"open","disposition":null,"evidence":null},{"id":"evidence_gap:mobile-money:single-source-1srgpt8","kind":"evidence_gap","region":"known_unknown","text":"\"Mobile money agent networks\" rests on one source. Has it been replicated independently?","severity":2,"how":"Search for an independent replication.","falsifier":null,"source":"rule","opened_at":"2026-11-17 15:33:47","status":"open","disposition":null,"evidence":null},{"id":"evidence_gap:mobile-money:weak-design-1rnlkqj","kind":"evidence_gap","region":"known_unknown","text":"The strongest design cited for \"Mobile money agent networks\" is observational, which cannot rule out confounding. Is there a trial or review?","severity":2,"how":"Search for a randomised trial or systematic review.","falsifier":null,"source":"rule","opened_at":"2026-11-17 15:33:47","status":"open","disposition":null,"evidence":null},{"id":"untested_assumption:mobile-money:assumptions-not-stated-y3r2zq","kind":"untested_assumption","region":"known_unknown","text":"No assumptions are stated for \"Mobile money agent networks\". Every claim rests on some (who it was tested on, who delivers it, what already exists). Which are they, and which were tested?","severity":2,"how":"List the assumptions; mark each tested or untested.","falsifier":null,"source":"rule","opened_at":"2026-11-17 15:33:47","status":"open","disposition":null,"evidence":null}],"closed":[]},"ors-zinc":{"challenged_at":null,"open":[{"id":"estimate_gap:ors-zinc:no-estimate-1gbjgur","kind":"estimate_gap","region":"known_unknown","text":"No quantified effect is recorded for \"Oral rehydration salts plus zinc as the standard first treatment\" in a common unit.","severity":2,"how":"Extract the effect size with its interval, or say why it cannot be.","falsifier":null,"source":"rule","opened_at":"2026-11-17 15:33:47","status":"open","disposition":null,"evidence":null},{"id":"evidence_gap:ors-zinc:single-source-x7ukes","kind":"evidence_gap","region":"known_unknown","text":"\"Oral rehydration salts plus zinc as the standard first treatment\" rests on one source. Has it been replicated independently?","severity":2,"how":"Search for an independent replication.","falsifier":null,"source":"rule","opened_at":"2026-11-17 15:33:47","status":"open","disposition":null,"evidence":null},{"id":"untested_assumption:ors-zinc:assumptions-not-stated-1oz6z2m","kind":"untested_assumption","region":"known_unknown","text":"No assumptions are stated for \"Oral rehydration salts plus zinc as the standard first treatment\". Every claim rests on some (who it was tested on, who delivers it, what already exists). Which are they, and which were tested?","severity":2,"how":"List the assumptions; mark each tested or untested.","falsifier":null,"source":"rule","opened_at":"2026-11-17 15:33:47","status":"open","disposition":null,"evidence":null}],"closed":[]},"tarl":{"challenged_at":null,"open":[{"id":"estimate_gap:tarl:no-estimate-iuwjrl","kind":"estimate_gap","region":"known_unknown","text":"No quantified effect is recorded for \"Teaching at the Right Level: group by skill, not grade\" in a common unit.","severity":2,"how":"Extract the effect size with its interval, or say why it cannot be.","falsifier":null,"source":"rule","opened_at":"2026-11-17 15:33:47","status":"open","disposition":null,"evidence":null},{"id":"evidence_gap:tarl:single-source-18q18y","kind":"evidence_gap","region":"known_unknown","text":"\"Teaching at the Right Level: group by skill, not grade\" rests on one source. Has it been replicated independently?","severity":2,"how":"Search for an independent replication.","falsifier":null,"source":"rule","opened_at":"2026-11-17 15:33:47","status":"open","disposition":null,"evidence":null},{"id":"untested_assumption:tarl:assumptions-not-stated-jkv5cc","kind":"untested_assumption","region":"known_unknown","text":"No assumptions are stated for \"Teaching at the Right Level: group by skill, not grade\". Every claim rests on some (who it was tested on, who delivers it, what already exists). Which are they, and which were tested?","severity":2,"how":"List the assumptions; mark each tested or untested.","falsifier":null,"source":"rule","opened_at":"2026-11-17 15:33:47","status":"open","disposition":null,"evidence":null}],"closed":[]},"vita":{"challenged_at":null,"open":[{"id":"estimate_gap:vita:no-estimate-1sljs6q","kind":"estimate_gap","region":"known_unknown","text":"No quantified effect is recorded for \"Vitamin A supplementation in deficient populations\" in a common unit.","severity":2,"how":"Extract the effect size with its interval, or say why it cannot be.","falsifier":null,"source":"rule","opened_at":"2026-11-17 15:33:47","status":"open","disposition":null,"evidence":null},{"id":"evidence_gap:vita:single-source-jllaib","kind":"evidence_gap","region":"known_unknown","text":"\"Vitamin A supplementation in deficient populations\" rests on one source. Has it been replicated independently?","severity":2,"how":"Search for an independent replication.","falsifier":null,"source":"rule","opened_at":"2026-11-17 15:33:47","status":"open","disposition":null,"evidence":null},{"id":"untested_assumption:vita:assumptions-not-stated-2j2irx","kind":"untested_assumption","region":"known_unknown","text":"No assumptions are stated for \"Vitamin A supplementation in deficient populations\". Every claim rests on some (who it was tested on, who delivers it, what already exists). Which are they, and which were tested?","severity":2,"how":"List the assumptions; mark each tested or untested.","falsifier":null,"source":"rule","opened_at":"2026-11-17 15:33:47","status":"open","disposition":null,"evidence":null}],"closed":[]},"women-leaders":{"challenged_at":null,"open":[{"id":"estimate_gap:women-leaders:no-estimate-ikckgh","kind":"estimate_gap","region":"known_unknown","text":"No quantified effect is recorded for \"Reserve leadership seats for women\" in a common unit.","severity":2,"how":"Extract the effect size with its interval, or say why it cannot be.","falsifier":null,"source":"rule","opened_at":"2026-11-17 15:33:47","status":"open","disposition":null,"evidence":null},{"id":"evidence_gap:women-leaders:single-source-1t0cppu","kind":"evidence_gap","region":"known_unknown","text":"\"Reserve leadership seats for women\" rests on one source. Has it been replicated independently?","severity":2,"how":"Search for an independent replication.","falsifier":null,"source":"rule","opened_at":"2026-11-17 15:33:47","status":"open","disposition":null,"evidence":null},{"id":"untested_assumption:women-leaders:assumptions-not-stated-twhbqk","kind":"untested_assumption","region":"known_unknown","text":"No assumptions are stated for \"Reserve leadership seats for women\". Every claim rests on some (who it was tested on, who delivers it, what already exists). Which are they, and which were tested?","severity":2,"how":"List the assumptions; mark each tested or untested.","falsifier":null,"source":"rule","opened_at":"2026-11-17 15:33:47","status":"open","disposition":null,"evidence":null}],"closed":[]},"finance":{"challenged_at":null,"open":[{"id":"unexplored_domain:finance:weak-only-eiujl9","kind":"unexplored_domain","region":"known_unknown","text":"Every solution listed for \"Adults without a financial account\" rests on weak designs. What does the strongest evidence say?","severity":2,"how":"open a new problem area with a first question","falsifier":null,"source":"rule","opened_at":"2026-11-17 15:33:47","status":"open","disposition":null,"evidence":null},{"id":"untested_assumption:finance:assumptions-not-stated-1ghp1kd","kind":"untested_assumption","region":"known_unknown","text":"No assumptions are stated for \"Adults without a financial account\". Every claim rests on some (who it was tested on, who delivers it, what already exists). Which are they, and which were tested?","severity":2,"how":"List the assumptions; mark each tested or untested.","falsifier":null,"source":"rule","opened_at":"2026-11-17 15:33:47","status":"open","disposition":null,"evidence":null}],"closed":[]},"ncd":{"challenged_at":null,"open":[{"id":"unexplored_domain:ncd:weak-only-1yib99q","kind":"unexplored_domain","region":"known_unknown","text":"Every solution listed for \"Early death from heart disease, cancer, diabetes and lung disease\" rests on weak designs. What does the strongest evidence say?","severity":2,"how":"open a new problem area with a first question","falsifier":null,"source":"rule","opened_at":"2026-11-17 15:33:47","status":"open","disposition":null,"evidence":null},{"id":"untested_assumption:ncd:assumptions-not-stated-tjvw3y","kind":"untested_assumption","region":"known_unknown","text":"No assumptions are stated for \"Early death from heart disease, cancer, diabetes and lung disease\". Every claim rests on some (who it was tested on, who delivers it, what already exists). Which are they, and which were tested?","severity":2,"how":"List the assumptions; mark each tested or untested.","falsifier":null,"source":"rule","opened_at":"2026-11-17 15:33:47","status":"open","disposition":null,"evidence":null}],"closed":[]},"cooking":{"challenged_at":null,"open":[{"id":"untested_assumption:cooking:assumptions-not-stated-lgac2r","kind":"untested_assumption","region":"known_unknown","text":"No assumptions are stated for \"Smoky cooking fuel\". Every claim rests on some (who it was tested on, who delivers it, what already exists). Which are they, and which were tested?","severity":2,"how":"List the assumptions; mark each tested or untested.","falsifier":null,"source":"rule","opened_at":"2026-11-17 15:33:47","status":"open","disposition":null,"evidence":null}],"closed":[]},"electricity":{"challenged_at":null,"open":[{"id":"untested_assumption:electricity:assumptions-not-stated-1hks9ga","kind":"untested_assumption","region":"known_unknown","text":"No assumptions are stated for \"People without electricity\". Every claim rests on some (who it was tested on, who delivers it, what already exists). Which are they, and which were tested?","severity":2,"how":"List the assumptions; mark each tested or untested.","falsifier":null,"source":"rule","opened_at":"2026-11-17 15:33:47","status":"open","disposition":null,"evidence":null}],"closed":[]},"hunger":{"challenged_at":null,"open":[{"id":"untested_assumption:hunger:assumptions-not-stated-zzc16q","kind":"untested_assumption","region":"known_unknown","text":"No assumptions are stated for \"Chronic hunger\". Every claim rests on some (who it was tested on, who delivers it, what already exists). Which are they, and which were tested?","severity":2,"how":"List the assumptions; mark each tested or untested.","falsifier":null,"source":"rule","opened_at":"2026-11-17 15:33:47","status":"open","disposition":null,"evidence":null}],"closed":[]},"neonatal":{"challenged_at":null,"open":[{"id":"untested_assumption:neonatal:assumptions-not-stated-17hofez","kind":"untested_assumption","region":"known_unknown","text":"No assumptions are stated for \"Newborn deaths\". Every claim rests on some (who it was tested on, who delivers it, what already exists). Which are they, and which were tested?","severity":2,"how":"List the assumptions; mark each tested or untested.","falsifier":null,"source":"rule","opened_at":"2026-11-17 15:33:47","status":"open","disposition":null,"evidence":null}],"closed":[]},"poverty":{"challenged_at":null,"open":[{"id":"untested_assumption:poverty:assumptions-not-stated-155m39u","kind":"untested_assumption","region":"known_unknown","text":"No assumptions are stated for \"Extreme poverty\". Every claim rests on some (who it was tested on, who delivers it, what already exists). Which are they, and which were tested?","severity":2,"how":"List the assumptions; mark each tested or untested.","falsifier":null,"source":"rule","opened_at":"2026-11-17 15:33:47","status":"open","disposition":null,"evidence":null}],"closed":[]},"road":{"challenged_at":null,"open":[{"id":"untested_assumption:road:assumptions-not-stated-mvj4pr","kind":"untested_assumption","region":"known_unknown","text":"No assumptions are stated for \"Road traffic deaths\". Every claim rests on some (who it was tested on, who delivers it, what already exists). Which are they, and which were tested?","severity":2,"how":"List the assumptions; mark each tested or untested.","falsifier":null,"source":"rule","opened_at":"2026-11-17 15:33:47","status":"open","disposition":null,"evidence":null}],"closed":[]},"stunting":{"challenged_at":null,"open":[{"id":"untested_assumption:stunting:assumptions-not-stated-1tb1u6t","kind":"untested_assumption","region":"known_unknown","text":"No assumptions are stated for \"Stunted growth in children\". Every claim rests on some (who it was tested on, who delivers it, what already exists). Which are they, and which were tested?","severity":2,"how":"List the assumptions; mark each tested or untested.","falsifier":null,"source":"rule","opened_at":"2026-11-17 15:33:47","status":"open","disposition":null,"evidence":null}],"closed":[]},"suicide":{"challenged_at":null,"open":[{"id":"untested_assumption:suicide:assumptions-not-stated-c02m8v","kind":"untested_assumption","region":"known_unknown","text":"No assumptions are stated for \"Suicide\". Every claim rests on some (who it was tested on, who delivers it, what already exists). Which are they, and which were tested?","severity":2,"how":"List the assumptions; mark each tested or untested.","falsifier":null,"source":"rule","opened_at":"2026-11-17 15:33:47","status":"open","disposition":null,"evidence":null}],"closed":[]},"under5":{"challenged_at":null,"open":[{"id":"untested_assumption:under5:assumptions-not-stated-frlhzg","kind":"untested_assumption","region":"known_unknown","text":"No assumptions are stated for \"Children dying before age five\". Every claim rests on some (who it was tested on, who delivers it, what already exists). Which are they, and which were tested?","severity":2,"how":"List the assumptions; mark each tested or untested.","falsifier":null,"source":"rule","opened_at":"2026-11-17 15:33:47","status":"open","disposition":null,"evidence":null}],"closed":[]},"water":{"challenged_at":null,"open":[{"id":"untested_assumption:water:assumptions-not-stated-cd0e8s","kind":"untested_assumption","region":"known_unknown","text":"No assumptions are stated for \"Unsafe drinking water\". Every claim rests on some (who it was tested on, who delivers it, what already exists). Which are they, and which were tested?","severity":2,"how":"List the assumptions; mark each tested or untested.","falsifier":null,"source":"rule","opened_at":"2026-11-17 15:33:47","status":"open","disposition":null,"evidence":null}],"closed":[]},"women-power":{"challenged_at":null,"open":[{"id":"untested_assumption:women-power:assumptions-not-stated-62qeft","kind":"untested_assumption","region":"known_unknown","text":"No assumptions are stated for \"Women missing from national parliaments\". Every claim rests on some (who it was tested on, who delivers it, what already exists). Which are they, and which were tested?","severity":2,"how":"List the assumptions; mark each tested or untested.","falsifier":null,"source":"rule","opened_at":"2026-11-17 15:33:47","status":"open","disposition":null,"evidence":null}],"closed":[]},"coverage":{"challenged_at":null,"open":[{"id":"audit_coverage:coverage:unchallenged-1dujp3x","kind":"audit_coverage","region":"ignorance_about_ignorance","text":"34 of 38 entries have never been red-teamed. The ignorance about the rest is unmeasured.","severity":1,"how":"The loop challenges the stalest entries each run.","falsifier":null,"source":"rule","opened_at":"2026-11-17 15:33:47","status":"open","disposition":null,"evidence":null}],"closed":[]},"domain:chronic-disease":{"challenged_at":null,"open":[{"id":"unexplored_domain:domain:chronic-disease:thin-domain-177p5r1","kind":"unexplored_domain","region":"known_unknown","text":"The Chronic disease area has fewer than 2 solutions. What else works here?","severity":1,"how":"open a new problem area with a first question","falsifier":null,"source":"rule","opened_at":"2026-11-17 15:33:47","status":"open","disposition":null,"evidence":null}],"closed":[]},"domain:digital-access":{"challenged_at":null,"open":[{"id":"unexplored_domain:domain:digital-access:thin-domain-j8znqh","kind":"unexplored_domain","region":"known_unknown","text":"The Digital access area has fewer than 2 solutions. What else works here?","severity":1,"how":"open a new problem area with a first question","falsifier":null,"source":"rule","opened_at":"2026-11-17 15:33:47","status":"open","disposition":null,"evidence":null}],"closed":[]},"domain:governance-and-gender":{"challenged_at":null,"open":[{"id":"unexplored_domain:domain:governance-and-gender:thin-domain-1jlvdiu","kind":"unexplored_domain","region":"known_unknown","text":"The Governance and gender area has fewer than 2 solutions. What else works here?","severity":1,"how":"open a new problem area with a first question","falsifier":null,"source":"rule","opened_at":"2026-11-17 15:33:47","status":"open","disposition":null,"evidence":null}],"closed":[]},"domain:infectious-disease":{"challenged_at":null,"open":[{"id":"unexplored_domain:domain:infectious-disease:thin-domain-14bnp8w","kind":"unexplored_domain","region":"known_unknown","text":"The Infectious disease area has fewer than 2 solutions. What else works here?","severity":1,"how":"open a new problem area with a first question","falsifier":null,"source":"rule","opened_at":"2026-11-17 15:33:47","status":"open","disposition":null,"evidence":null}],"closed":[]},"domain:maternal-health":{"challenged_at":null,"open":[{"id":"unexplored_domain:domain:maternal-health:thin-domain-na3vib","kind":"unexplored_domain","region":"known_unknown","text":"The Maternal health area has fewer than 2 solutions. What else works here?","severity":1,"how":"open a new problem area with a first question","falsifier":null,"source":"rule","opened_at":"2026-11-17 15:33:47","status":"open","disposition":null,"evidence":null}],"closed":[]},"domain:mental-health":{"challenged_at":null,"open":[{"id":"unexplored_domain:domain:mental-health:thin-domain-quvvhs","kind":"unexplored_domain","region":"known_unknown","text":"The Mental health area has fewer than 2 solutions. What else works here?","severity":1,"how":"open a new problem area with a first question","falsifier":null,"source":"rule","opened_at":"2026-11-17 15:33:47","status":"open","disposition":null,"evidence":null}],"closed":[]},"domain:safety":{"challenged_at":null,"open":[{"id":"unexplored_domain:domain:safety:thin-domain-1t7eu7s","kind":"unexplored_domain","region":"known_unknown","text":"The Safety area has fewer than 2 solutions. What else works here?","severity":1,"how":"open a new problem area with a first question","falsifier":null,"source":"rule","opened_at":"2026-11-17 15:33:47","status":"open","disposition":null,"evidence":null}],"closed":[]}},"instrument":{"source":"Quni-Gudzinas, Universal Ignorance Audit, doi 10.5281/zenodo.21901984","phases":["Surface the structure","Stress-test the frame","Multiply perspectives","Uncover the hidden forces","Act"],"questions":[{"n":1,"phase":"Surface the structure","text":"What are the hidden assumptions and scaffolds holding this situation or belief up?"},{"n":2,"phase":"Surface the structure","text":"Where might the map be mistaken for the territory?"},{"n":3,"phase":"Surface the structure","text":"What is the wobble? Where is the tension, anomaly, or thing that does not fit?"},{"n":4,"phase":"Stress-test the frame","text":"What if the opposite were true?"},{"n":5,"phase":"Stress-test the frame","text":"What would a world look like in which this was false?"},{"n":6,"phase":"Stress-test the frame","text":"If I changed the base, origin, center, or frame, what would remain the same?"},{"n":7,"phase":"Multiply perspectives","text":"How would this look to a radically different observer?"},{"n":8,"phase":"Multiply perspectives","text":"Who knows something about this that I do not, and what would they say is my biggest blind spot?"},{"n":9,"phase":"Uncover the hidden forces","text":"Who benefits from the current framing? Who or what is silenced, excluded, or harmed?"},{"n":10,"phase":"Uncover the hidden forces","text":"What is the most dangerous question I could ask about this, the one that threatens my certainties?"},{"n":11,"phase":"Uncover the hidden forces","text":"What does this confusion or ignorance feel like, and what does the feeling itself know?"},{"n":12,"phase":"Act","text":"What do I already know but am pretending not to know?"},{"n":13,"phase":"Act","text":"What can I do with this uncertainty right now, without needing to resolve it?"},{"n":14,"phase":"Act","text":"What does the unknown want from me?"},{"n":15,"phase":"Act","text":"What question am I not asking that I should be asking, given all of the above?"}]}}