Practical SolutionsEvidence for what works

A regulated pollution market with continuous monitoring

evidence-backednot yet practical · 2/8design: randomised trial

A randomised study in Surat, India found that a cap-and-trade market for particulate emissions, with continuous monitors, lowered emissions at the plants in the market relative to plants under standard rules.

Key messages

  • Evidence: evidence-backed. Strongest design cited: randomised trial.
  • Implementation: not yet practical (2 of 8). Cost to start is high; adoption is trial-only.
  • Start with: Install continuous monitors at 50 plants and publish readings; trial a small permit market among them for one year.
  • Main limit: A single city and industry; figures are the authors' own and need re-checking against the paper before use.

Where it works

Industrial plants in Surat, Gujarat, India.

What it takes

Continuous emission monitors, a permit cap, a trading platform, and an enforcement regime.

Who can act: State pollution control boards, environment ministries.

Cheapest first test

Install continuous monitors at 50 plants and publish readings; trial a small permit market among them for one year.

Can it be implemented?

Verdict
not yet practical · 2/8
Cost to start
high. Monitors and a market platform.
Real-world adoption
trial-only
Delivery channel
none identified
Holds remit and money
state pollution control boards

Score 3 to 8 = cost to start (low 3, medium 2, high 1) + real-world adoption (scaled 3, piloted 2, trial-only 1) + an existing delivery channel (2). 7 or more is ready to implement; 5 or 6 is implementable with effort; below 5 is held back as not yet practical.

Evidence and sources

Randomised trial: Participants or places assigned by chance.

  • Greenstone, Pande, Ryan and Sudarshan, "Can Pollution Markets Work in Developing Countries? Experimental Evidence from India", 2023
    Plants assigned to the market emitted noticeably less particulate matter than control plants; the authors report reductions of about a fifth to a third.
    Find this paper on Europe PMC

Verification: not yet checked against the source No automatic check is defined for this entry yet, so the figures are the source's own, unconfirmed here.

Limits

A single city and industry; figures are the authors' own and need re-checking against the paper before use.

Use and cite this entry

Permanent link: https://tenant-ps-web.ultrastable.workers.dev/solutions/emissions-market

Practical Solutions. "A regulated pollution market with continuous monitoring". https://tenant-ps-web.ultrastable.workers.dev/solutions/emissions-market. Accessed 2026-11-17.

This entry as JSON · Compare with others · Report an error or suggest a correction