Clean-fuel stoves (the largest trial found no clear pneumonia benefit)
mixed evidenceimplementable with effort · 5/8design: randomised trial
A large multi-country trial that gave households LPG stoves and fuel did not find a significant reduction in severe infant pneumonia, so health benefits are less certain than often assumed.
Key messages
- Evidence: mixed evidence. Strongest design cited: randomised trial.
- Implementation: implementable with effort (5 of 8). Cost to start is high; adoption is piloted.
- Start with: Measure household exposure (PM2.5) before and after in 100 homes to check the stove is actually used exclusively before claiming health gains.
- Main limit: Mixed result: mixed fuel use can leave exposure high; exposure and other outcomes (blood pressure, birth weight) have separate reports.
Where it works
Guatemala, India, Peru and Rwanda, 2018-2021.
What it takes
Stoves, a reliable fuel supply, and support for exclusive use of the clean stove.
Who can act: Energy and health ministries, clean-cooking programmes.
Cheapest first test
Measure household exposure (PM2.5) before and after in 100 homes to check the stove is actually used exclusively before claiming health gains.
Can it be implemented?
- Verdict
- implementable with effort · 5/8
- Cost to start
- high. Stove plus continuing fuel supply.
- Real-world adoption
- piloted
- Delivery channel
- clean-cooking programmes
- Holds remit and money
- energy ministries
Score 3 to 8 = cost to start (low 3, medium 2, high 1) + real-world adoption (scaled 3, piloted 2, trial-only 1) + an existing delivery channel (2). 7 or more is ready to implement; 5 or 6 is implementable with effort; below 5 is held back as not yet practical.
Evidence and sources
Randomised trial: Participants or places assigned by chance.
- Clasen and the HAPIN investigators, New England Journal of Medicine, 2022
Randomised trial of a liquefied petroleum gas stove intervention in Guatemala, India, Peru and Rwanda: no significant reduction in severe pneumonia in infants.
Find this paper on Europe PMC
Verification: not yet checked against the source No automatic check is defined for this entry yet, so the figures are the source's own, unconfirmed here.
Limits
Mixed result: mixed fuel use can leave exposure high; exposure and other outcomes (blood pressure, birth weight) have separate reports.
Use and cite this entry
Permanent link: https://tenant-ps-web.ultrastable.workers.dev/solutions/clean-cooking
Practical Solutions. "Clean-fuel stoves (the largest trial found no clear pneumonia benefit)". https://tenant-ps-web.ultrastable.workers.dev/solutions/clean-cooking. Accessed 2026-11-17.
This entry as JSON · Compare with others · Report an error or suggest a correction